LUKE: Innocent of guilty?

First topic message reminder :

Do you think Luke is inocent or guilty?
I think he is inocent, [read my therie], but what do you think?
reply here:

same here. luke is so going to Elysuim because he died a true hero. he saved Olympus.

Yeah!

Daughter of Athena wrote:WE ARE ON TOPIC!!!!

I know but not on other topics. Off topic Please delete

((It is offtopic bringing it up in a thread which contains no offtopic-ness, so I shall delete this.)

That is confusing!

Luke wrote:

Daughter of Athena wrote:WE ARE ON TOPIC!!!!

I know but not on other topics. Off topic Please delete

Athena wats your reason for thinking that luke is innocent.

My reason is that he allowed himself to be taken over by the Titan. he must have origionaly descided to join him, saying that he died a hero in the end is like saying:
A murderer who has killed more then ten people rescued a cat from a tree. But was then ran over by a car protecting a cat. Sure he did some good at the end but it doesn't relieve him of his pprevious offences.

I think it does. my religion beleaves that.

Yeah I think that he was a hero and a bad person. No one will forget what he did before even if he was a hero in the end!

Luke wasnt a bad person!