Percy Immortal?

First topic message reminder :

Should it have happened at the end of book five

It wouldnt have ruined the book ot would have been kinda cool

For you it wouldn't have for me it would.

Percy immortal thats awsome

YEAHHHHH

i think that percy being immortal would sort of ruin the book if he continued on this series. because then you wouldnt hear from any of the other characters too much.

Agreed.
*Percy meets monster. Stabs monster doesn't get hurt the end.*
Thats what it would have been like.

yup

Him and ares fighting for an eternity haha

Greek_Geek wrote:Agreed.
*Percy meets monster. Stabs monster doesn't get hurt the end.*
Thats what it would have been like.

Boooorrriiinnnngggg!

Haha....it wouldn't be as interesting!

yeah unless somone figured out how to kill immortals

That would be hard though!

Agreed.

Haha yeah!

what about that fish thing if you burn its entrails or somthin

?????????????????????

In the third book that fish thing

Daughter of Athena wrote:

Daughter of Athena wrote:No offence but Eregon cannot even compare!

PJO books are wayyy better!

i know!!!!!!! there better the harry potter books(almost)

Back on topic And the inherintence books where better no offennse to PJO. The first printing of 2.5 million copies of the fantasy novel was the largest initial run for a Random House Children's Books title in the publisher's history. The book was released at 12:01 a.m. on Saturday, September 20, 2008, so booksellers could host midnight launch parties, such as those held for the Harry Potter series. More than 2,500 bookstores held Brisingr parties. Random House reported that 550,000 copies of Brisingr were sold its first day. Random House's Listening Library division published the audiobook simultaneously in the U.S.
Paolini's fantasy novels have been enormously popular, particularly with teens and and adults. According to the publisher, 12.5 million copies of Eragon and Eldest, the first two books in the Inheritance Cycle, have been sold worldwide. Where as Harry Potter 7 sold over 11 million copies in the first 24 hours. Thats more than the whole Percy Jackson series ever sold. So i would say Eragons better. And potter better than it

NOPE ITS NOT!!!

Back on topic

When people want the topic to get back in the flow. Its often a good idea the person who's picking it up too say something like,"come on its getting off topic here, anyways what do you guys hink about Percy refusing to be immortal' Thats all
And do you think Percy would have shosen to be immortal if all his friends were offered it?

Greek_Geek wrote:When people want the topic to get back in the flow. Its often a good idea the person who's picking it up too say something like,"come on its getting off topic here, anyways what do you guys hink about Percy refusing to be immortal' Thats all
And do you think Percy would have shosen to be immortal if all his friends were offered it?

maybe. just maybe.

Haha yeah......!

Sorry Greek it wil not happen again