Percy Immortal?

Should it have happened at the end of book five

no
Percy chosing the moral of demigods of imortality for his personal gain is very symbolic, and it a great theme of the book. If Percy chose imortality, then It would have destroyed the books for me. Besides, enstead of doing the traditional fary tale like ending, Rick Riordan gave the plotline a twist.

I thought it was predictable. He and annabeth should have been immortal

That would have been to pradictable

yeah i guess

i would never think percy would want to become immortal. hes likes annabeth, so if he was made immortal, it would have ruined the book

not if they both were

that is true but annabeth didn't get offered and it would be horrible! :ninja: plus predictable stuff bugs me

But I kinda wish he did!

me too

i also think that it would have been weird. i mean, percy immortal AND annabeth. weird. but yea, i wish percy did become immortal, too

Annabeth should have been immortal rather than Percy

why do u say that??????

Shes the reason cronos didnt kill them both at the end of book five

oooohhhh yea right

yeah percy didnt do anything cept pwn everyone on the bridge in book5

No he like helped everyone kill monsters!!! I say that Annabeth and Percy should have both gotten to turn immortal! It would have been a pretty good ending like that!

I disagree. They ou-live Nico, Grover and all there other friends.

What??

Grovers immortal but he can die from a blade or weapon

Seriously? I didn't know he was immortal!

he can die hes kinda like the followers of artemis he will live forever

So he will live forever if he doesn't get hurt?

yeah even they he will get reincarnated

Awww sweet!