LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
+10
percyjackson101
Demeterlikescereal
apollogrl10
Luke
Daughter of Athena
athenachick
eragon5217
Greek_Geek
riczhang
Christof
14 posters
MortalNet's Forum :: Books :: Other
Page 1 of 4
Page 1 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
Do you think Luke is inocent or guilty?
I think he is inocent, [read my therie], but what do you think?
reply here:
I think he is inocent, [read my therie], but what do you think?
reply here:
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
My Therie
Christof's therie wrote:
At the end of The Battle of the Labyrinth, we see Nico suddenly appeared out of thin air.
"
Nico taped his silver ring. "But that's not the real reason I've come.
I've found out some things. I've come to make you an offer."
"What?"
"The way to beat Luke. If I'm right, It's the only way you'll stand a chance."
I took a deap breath. "OK, I'm listening." [BOL page 361] "
Then Nico get's distracted by the blue birthday cake, and the book ends.
You probably were so excited and sad that the book was
over that you missed this important bit of info. Nico has a plan, and
it might work.
We are reminded of this by the author in The Sword of
Hades [The Demigod Files, Page 133]. If this isn't important, Rick
wouldn't mention it more than once.
The plan will involve the underworld, since Nico is a
son of Hades, and Hades is the god of the Underworld. We can be shure
that Nico wil be conjuring alot of dead in book five.
Rick Riordan had confirmed that we will be seeing
Luke's mom in book 5, but why? Well, we do know that Luke ran away from
home, thoe we don't know why. We can only quess that what happened was
simular to what happened to Annebeth (She ran away from her parent
because he married a second wife that she didn't like.) of Thalia (she
ran away because she didn't like her mom, who was mean to her, even
thoe Thalia loved her mom.). Lukes mother could of been in thoes two
situations.
What also could have happened was that Luke's mother
was killed, and Luke ran for it, eather to escape the authority's or to
escape the Orphanage.
Luke's mother is dead. We don't know how she was
killed, but w\e know that she is dead. If she wasn't dead, then Nico
wouldn't be involved at all, since the dead are his speciality.
Luke loved his mother (you love you're mother no
matter what/who she is), and It is possible that Cronos bribed Luke
into his service in the promise of getting his mother back. Or, Cronos
could have made an ilusion of his mother saying something along the
lighns of (join Cronos for me.).
Nico's plan is to do the same thing Cronos did, bribe
Luke with his mom. Or Nico could just conger Luke's mother up, and
Lukes mother would tell her that she loved him, and to abandon Cronos.
Luke would then do this because he loved her (you love you're mother no
matter what/who she is).'
Even thoe Cronos inhabits Luke's body, Cronos is not under complete
control. Rachel managed to bring Luke back temporarily by hitting him
with a plastic hairbrush. When Luke see's his mom, that will be enough
to get him out of Cronos' control, permenetly, or long enough to tell
percy something that will defeat Cronos (a piece of info, where a
weapon is hidden, ect.).
Hestia comes in because she would help Nico because his plan does
not involve violence. She would assist him and Percy in every way she
can. Even thoe It does look like Percy wont be using Riptide allot, He
will still have to use it to distract Cronos.
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
Totally guilty! It was his evilness that got him possessed.
riczhang- Staff
- Imortal Parent : Zeus
Number of posts : 3996
Age : 28
Location : Blood Tower, Tower of London
Humor : Don't upset the All Seeing eye...
Reputation : 12
Registration date : 2009-04-16
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
no way
Cronos did some mind numbing thing that forced him to serve him
Cronos did some mind numbing thing that forced him to serve him
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
In someway i can see both sides of the argument on 1 side he is guilty he betrayed his friends on the other hand kronos can cloud ppls judgement thats whet he does.
Greek_Geek- Staff
- Imortal Parent : Posidon
Number of posts : 367
Reputation : 1
Registration date : 2009-02-21
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
Cronus only bent Luke's mind cause he was thinking that already.
riczhang- Staff
- Imortal Parent : Zeus
Number of posts : 3996
Age : 28
Location : Blood Tower, Tower of London
Humor : Don't upset the All Seeing eye...
Reputation : 12
Registration date : 2009-04-16
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
Or, acording to my editorial, Cronos bribed Luke with his mom
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
I can prove my theory in The Lightning theif. It says so when Luke and Percy were having coke near the end of the book that Luke said after his quest he dreamt of tearing down olympus stone by stone and then he dreamed to the pit which is where he met cronus.
riczhang- Staff
- Imortal Parent : Zeus
Number of posts : 3996
Age : 28
Location : Blood Tower, Tower of London
Humor : Don't upset the All Seeing eye...
Reputation : 12
Registration date : 2009-04-16
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
but something went wrong during his quest, and It took him to the Titans headquarters
never mind, we'll find out soon
never mind, we'll find out soon
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
Ok guys!
spoiler alert!!!!! If you have not read The Last Olympian, please don't read this post:
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
/b]Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
/b]Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
/b]Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
/b]Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Luke is inocent!!!!!
I was right!!!!!
OMG
And you said I wasn't wrong, eh. (Ok, I was wrong about the fact that Luke was forced againsed his will to serve cronos, etleased in the begining!
But he was inocent!!!!!
post what you think about this here:
spoiler alert!!!!! If you have not read The Last Olympian, please don't read this post:
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
/b]Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
/b]Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
/b]Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
/b]Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Warning: Spoilers ahead
Luke is inocent!!!!!
I was right!!!!!
OMG
And you said I wasn't wrong, eh. (Ok, I was wrong about the fact that Luke was forced againsed his will to serve cronos, etleased in the begining!
But he was inocent!!!!!
post what you think about this here:
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
Maybe I was wrong but I was close on my Nico and Bianca theory and that they were sent there to be protected.Except I got Cronus and hades wrong)
riczhang- Staff
- Imortal Parent : Zeus
Number of posts : 3996
Age : 28
Location : Blood Tower, Tower of London
Humor : Don't upset the All Seeing eye...
Reputation : 12
Registration date : 2009-04-16
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
OK, I was really mad about the fact that the Sandoller therie was not right.
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
I thought that how percy spends the sandollar is really lame
riczhang- Staff
- Imortal Parent : Zeus
Number of posts : 3996
Age : 28
Location : Blood Tower, Tower of London
Humor : Don't upset the All Seeing eye...
Reputation : 12
Registration date : 2009-04-16
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
yes but you were also wrong when u said that lukes mother was dead! HAHA! and i told u she was alive and u dint believe me!
eragon5217- Moderators
- Number of posts : 31
Age : 27
Location : VT
Reputation : 0
Registration date : 2008-12-27
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
you're right about that. and you were right about the sand-doller theory. *sigh* But I did get the Luke is innocent theory right!
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
the only way to know if hes innocent or not.... IS IF YOU READ THE LAST OLYMPIAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! then its easier to go and argue sides: THUS we can tell whether Luke is really and truly innocent or not. but, after reading PJO #5, i believe hes completely INNOCENT
athenachick- Olympian Demigod
- Imortal Parent : Athena
Number of posts : 593
Age : 28
Location : Camp Half-Blood, Athena Cabin (summer) Pittsburgh, PA (all other times)!!!!!!!
Humor : TAYLOR THE LATTE BOY!!!! go on youtube and listen to it!!!!!! (:
Reputation : 6
Registration date : 2009-07-16
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
We both have read the Last Olympian, by the way.
Christof- Webmaster
- Imortal Parent : Kronos
Number of posts : 610
Location : Somewhere in Cyberspace
Reputation : 16
Registration date : 2008-12-20
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
oh ok, then its easier for us to understand, sorta
athenachick- Olympian Demigod
- Imortal Parent : Athena
Number of posts : 593
Age : 28
Location : Camp Half-Blood, Athena Cabin (summer) Pittsburgh, PA (all other times)!!!!!!!
Humor : TAYLOR THE LATTE BOY!!!! go on youtube and listen to it!!!!!! (:
Reputation : 6
Registration date : 2009-07-16
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
I think he was kinda both!
Daughter of Athena- Moderators
- Imortal Parent : Athena
Number of posts : 1050
Location : Mortal.net
Humor : I think of random stuff!
Reputation : 0
Registration date : 2009-07-25
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
athenachick wrote:the only way to know if hes innocent or not.... IS IF YOU READ THE LAST OLYMPIAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! then its easier to go and argue sides: THUS we can tell whether Luke is really and truly innocent or not. but, after reading PJO #5, i believe hes completely INNOCENT
ME TOO!
Luke- Olympian Demigod
- Imortal Parent : Hermes
Number of posts : 959
Age : 29
Location : Pittsburgh
Reputation : 3
Registration date : 2009-07-22
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
I don't think he is completely innocent because then why did he is help Kronos so much? But in a way I think he was innocent because Kronos twisted minds. But he had so many chances to get out.
Daughter of Athena- Moderators
- Imortal Parent : Athena
Number of posts : 1050
Location : Mortal.net
Humor : I think of random stuff!
Reputation : 0
Registration date : 2009-07-25
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
Hermes ignored him
Luke- Olympian Demigod
- Imortal Parent : Hermes
Number of posts : 959
Age : 29
Location : Pittsburgh
Reputation : 3
Registration date : 2009-07-22
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
well i think hermes ignored him because he knew he could corrupt his fate...he knew he wud be good and he stopped in from time to time...
apollogrl10- Undetermined Demigod
- Imortal Parent : Apollo
Number of posts : 191
Reputation : 0
Registration date : 2009-08-14
Re: LUKE: Innocent of guilty?
yeah he could have visited a little more
Luke- Olympian Demigod
- Imortal Parent : Hermes
Number of posts : 959
Age : 29
Location : Pittsburgh
Reputation : 3
Registration date : 2009-07-22
Page 1 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
MortalNet's Forum :: Books :: Other
Page 1 of 4
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|
Mon Nov 15, 2010 10:35 pm by Azteza
» 51 Things That Conner and Travis Stoll Are NOT Allowed To Do
Mon Nov 15, 2010 10:32 pm by Azteza
» Word association game!
Wed Oct 27, 2010 10:52 pm by Posidonsdaughter
» 3.0 - having a few bugs - Houston we have a problem
Tue Oct 26, 2010 10:30 pm by Posidonsdaughter
» 3 word story
Sun Oct 24, 2010 10:51 pm by Posidonsdaughter
» The Inkheart Trilogy
Sun Oct 24, 2010 10:48 pm by Posidonsdaughter
» demigod things
Sun Oct 24, 2010 10:44 pm by Posidonsdaughter
» The Lost Hero - thoughts and reactions --SPOILER ALART
Sun Oct 24, 2010 10:33 pm by Posidonsdaughter
» POLL for reactions to THE LOST HERO
Sun Oct 24, 2010 10:28 pm by Posidonsdaughter