LUKE: Innocent of guilty?

First topic message reminder :

Do you think Luke is inocent or guilty?
I think he is inocent, [read my therie], but what do you think?
reply here:

Yes he technology was!

Give me ten good reasons

He is evil 1
He did mean things to Annabeth 2
He did mean things to Thalia 3
He served Kronos 4
He back stabbed Percy 5
He back stabbed everyone in camp 6
He didn't respect his father 7
He did things without thinking 8
He broke everyones trust 9
And lastly he hurt his mother 10

Daughter of Athena wrote:He is evil 1
He did mean things to Annabeth 2
He did mean things to Thalia 3
He served Kronos 4
He back stabbed Percy 5
He back stabbed everyone in camp 6
He didn't respect his father 7
He did things without thinking 8
He broke everyones trust 9
And lastly he hurt his mother 10

1: He is evil is not a reason its just an adjetive.
2:Yes he did mean things to Annabeth but he made it up to her by coming to her for help and she spat in his face.
3: He never really bothered with Thalia.
4: He was tricked into serving him and was brain washed
5: Again he was twisted by Cronos.
6: Once again he was twisted/brain washed
7: He didnt respect his father because his father never bothered with him or even acknowledged him.
8: Thats not a reason for being evil that just unintelligent,
9: This reason is the same as 6 and 5 you just refrased them.
10: He didnt hurt her she hurt herself she tried to become the oracle,

Luke wrote:

Daughter of Athena wrote:He is evil 1
He did mean things to Annabeth 2
He did mean things to Thalia 3
He served Kronos 4
He back stabbed Percy 5
He back stabbed everyone in camp 6
He didn't respect his father 7
He did things without thinking 8
He broke everyones trust 9
And lastly he hurt his mother 10

1: He is evil is not a reason its just an adjetive.
2:Yes he did mean things to Annabeth but he made it up to her by coming to her for help and she spat in his face.
3: He never really bothered with Thalia.
4: He was tricked into serving him and was brain washed
5: Again he was twisted by Cronos.
6: Once again he was twisted/brain washed
7: He didnt respect his father because his father never bothered with him or even acknowledged him.
8: Thats not a reason for being evil that just unintelligent,
9: This reason is the same as 6 and 5 you just refrased them.
10: He didnt hurt her she hurt herself she tried to become the oracle,

YOU ARE NOT LOOKING OUTSIDE OF THE BOX FOR HEAVENS SAKE!!!!

Your just mad that i was able to prove all your reasons wrong

But you didn't. And that is my opinion you cannot change it!

So does anyone besides D.O.V think luke was good

Nope!

I do.

I kinda like him but not a lot!

I think hes cooler than Percy

I don't... he was no where as nice as Percy was!

nice people are all the same like clarrisse was cool and good

Whats you're point?

Percy is the same as all the other heros in my opinion

Not really not from Greek mythology!

i think he is innocent because he kind of couldn't help the fact that he was possesed by evil

Luke you were right. Tell your sister you were right. Father I want dto save you. you already have luke. (end of episode 6 Return of the Jedi.


I believe Lukes pride was, and this hurt enables him to be swayed to thdark side --Kronos. Then once possed could not break free. He faliled and no campers could go on a quest. Hatred found its way to Kronos, and master liar he is, fed his anger towards Hermes and what envisioned vindication upons Lronos' return to power. His evaporating was not discussed with Kronos.

Luke was guilty. But through Percy saw the chance to redeem himself and took it. You end up feeeling really sorry for him.

he was innocent cause hermes left him alone.

willrox wrote:he was innocent cause hermes left him alone.

No, everyone has a choice, like Janus said,"Choose". He could've chose to be good and not evil but he took the wrong choice. I'm a big believer in choices so I'm probably influenced by my beliefs.

I think he was innocent, because at the end, he found his mistake and he told percy not to let it happen again. He turned his back on the Gods, but he FOUND HIS MISTAKE!!! so he was definetly innocent.but he did feel bad about what had happened....

tinkerirock wrote:I think he was innocent, because at the end, he found his mistake and he told percy not to let it happen again. He turned his back on the Gods, but he FOUND HIS MISTAKE!!! so he was definetly innocent.but he did feel bad about what had happened....

No he was guilty but later got to his senses but it was too late to repent, it was just worded so we'd fell bad for him and think that he is innocent.

ok yea thats pretty much it though if u think about it............

tinkerirock wrote:ok yea thats pretty much it though if u think about it............

I still don't get why people think he is innocent, but I get why people feel bad for him.