Zia's memory, do you think she'll remember? - SPOILER ALERT IF YOU HAVEN'T READ TRP

Thought we get into discussions on the Red Pyramid book.

SPOILER ALERT


She was never there what do you think?

I think Zia doesn't remember because Desjardins, or iskandar errased hert memorie

Well if the Shabti was reporting bak, when Carter and Sadie find her I think she'll have the memories, cause the shabti did say that she wanted a date in the mall, so that has to refer to at least some of the events have gotten to her.

yea, like some main points could do it.

tinkerirock wrote:yea, like some main points could do it.

It'd be awesome if Carter was trying to explain what happened and Zia says "Yeah, I know, I've been there done that."

Somehow I feel that Rick will make it a plot twist that she doesn't remember at first, but then the shabti memory will get to her so she helps Carter and Sadie.

Posidonsdaughter wrote:Somehow I feel that Rick will make it a plot twist that she doesn't remember at first, but then the shabti memory will get to her so she helps Carter and Sadie.

Almost like coming back slowly and slowly, or he could have her have flashbacks all the time but never knowing what the memory was or what it was about....

But that would be like the Shabti memory got damaged.

Posidonsdaughter wrote:But that would be like the Shabti memory got damaged.

But it might've cause the shabti did fall apart in the end.(Not literally but you get my idea)

that would be a twist. i don't think it would be the same thing that the shabti was there instead of Zia herself, because it's only the memories, but the actual experience is different, you know? like if someone gave you their memories, but it wouldn't be the same as you actually being there

percyjackson101 wrote:that would be a twist. i don't think it would be the same thing that the shabti was there instead of Zia herself, because it's only the memories, but the actual experience is different, you know? like if someone gave you their memories, but it wouldn't be the same as you actually being there

Not if they were implanted in such a way that they become part of you.

riczhang wrote:

percyjackson101 wrote:that would be a twist. i don't think it would be the same thing that the shabti was there instead of Zia herself, because it's only the memories, but the actual experience is different, you know? like if someone gave you their memories, but it wouldn't be the same as you actually being there

Not if they were implanted in such a way that they become part of you.

that makes sense. it would be creepy if the memories were so real that she couldn't tell which ones were her's or the shabti's

percyjackson101 wrote:

riczhang wrote:

percyjackson101 wrote:that would be a twist. i don't think it would be the same thing that the shabti was there instead of Zia herself, because it's only the memories, but the actual experience is different, you know? like if someone gave you their memories, but it wouldn't be the same as you actually being there

Not if they were implanted in such a way that they become part of you.

that makes sense. it would be creepy if the memories were so real that she couldn't tell which ones were her's or the shabti's

But technically the Shabti was filling in for her, so wouldn't it be her memories by technicality?

I think so.

yea, but she could get all mixed up even if it was her own memories, since they weren't naturally regained.

yes

so... what do we say now...?

My take? I think she'll remember. I mean, Rick could very well choose to have her not remember as a plot twist, but I don't think so.

Yeah, Rick always throws a twist in there, but I think she'll remember and the twist will be in her memories.

I think this thread is done. LOCKED