Do you think Luke and Annabeth loved eachother?

First topic message reminder :

Do you think Luke and Annabeth loved each other like I mean Love as in heart.

yea at one point thats true!! i still think that annabeth mite of gone off when luke was overtook by Kronos

If she didn't go off with Luke when they met in San Francisco she wouldn't turn to him once he was possessed.

Alright so ik it might be a possiblility. But I love Luke so there is no way that he loved anyone else.. in my perfect little world. Yeah. Luke Castellan. What a stud. Somehow i always seem to fall for the bad boy! Lol wow. So yeah. I also think Annabeth always loved Percy more.

yea like she said in the book when he was dying "I always loved you like a brother.." or something like that. I thik Percabeth is like kinda hard to tell right now because well yea

Yeah, I think that's all it ever was with Luke and Annabeth: brother/sister type stuff. Percy and Annabeth work cuz', when you think about it, they balance each other out.

I definately agree with that. But, (and don't get mad at me for saying this, I'm on Percabeth's side!!) if you think about the first book, Annabeth was always blushing around Luke. Then as the stories go on, she falls for Percy. And really if you think about it, Luke is way older than her in the first place. Percy is perfect for her. No one else could be better. But don't take my word for it.

I totally agree. It makes sence... I like Percabeth too... its cute very cute.

hem hem... i also kind of like percabeth... in a way... and i think annabeth liked percy a lot more than she liked luke. She was better for percy anyways. Wouldnt it be an interesting twist if there was someone else Luke liked? ......that would be cool...

thaila maybe?? well shes a huntress, how about clairesse??????? GASP!

tinkerirock wrote:thaila maybe?? well shes a huntress, how about clairesse??????? GASP!

I think those two are too different for Percy, one being immortal and the other being very rude/rough.

DiaClaireNoel wrote:hem hem... i also kind of like percabeth... in a way... and i think annabeth liked percy a lot more than she liked luke. She was better for percy anyways. Wouldnt it be an interesting twist if there was someone else Luke liked? ......that would be cool...

Luke liked Thalia, and Annabeth was his little sister, nothing more nothing less.

Yeah but I don't really think he liked Thalia either...I think they were both sisters to him... it was his family that would never betray him like he felt Hermes did. And Dia yes...it would be funny if someone else liked Luke... but not clarisse...she likes Chris

o yea!! well i guess that it WAS a percabeth thing, sorta, but not with luke and annabeth nor thaila

TheSilverHunter wrote:

DiaClaireNoel wrote:hem hem... i also kind of like percabeth... in a way... and i think annabeth liked percy a lot more than she liked luke. She was better for percy anyways. Wouldnt it be an interesting twist if there was someone else Luke liked? ......that would be cool...

Luke liked Thalia, and Annabeth was his little sister, nothing more nothing less.

But, do you think that Thalia like Luke????

idk, maybe before she became a huntress. Like she never really showed affection for Luk,e but its a possibility.

Personally, it doesn't seem likely to me, but if there's one thing I've learned in my life, anything is possible.

Nahh... I think Thalia was always to independent for a man. Plus I think she felt that Luke was a brother to her.

riczhang wrote:

TheSilverHunter wrote:

DiaClaireNoel wrote:hem hem... i also kind of like percabeth... in a way... and i think annabeth liked percy a lot more than she liked luke. She was better for percy anyways. Wouldnt it be an interesting twist if there was someone else Luke liked? ......that would be cool...

Luke liked Thalia, and Annabeth was his little sister, nothing more nothing less.

But, do you think that Thalia like Luke????

Yea thats why she didn't become a Hunter when she first met the Hunters....

Okay, well, I havnt read the other responses because I have homework I should be doing, but my opinion is that she liked him as family more then like-like.

yea i agree, but Rick really doesn't explain it well enough for us to make solid conclusions.

I gotta agree with Mark D. on this one.

I think she loved him as a brother. It could have been something more but in the end she loved him as a brother.

yea so ALL IN ALL: annabeth loved luke as a bro, but not realy 'love':love. just kinda--yeaaaaa

Daughter of Athena wrote:I think they did but Annabeth loved Percy more!

Yeah, it's a mix of that I think. I think she though she loved Luke, but compared to how she felt about Percy... well, that was nothing. ^^,

I really think that she loved Luke as more than a friend at one point, but that Percy changed her mind and that she only loved Luke as a brother after she fell in love with Percy.